Skip to content

Corporate Manslaughter
and Management Liability

Language Matters D&O/Management Risks
Neil McCarthy

Written by

Neil McCarthy

5 min read

Almost two decades have passed since the Corporate Manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Act 2007 (the “Act”) came into force on 6 April 2008. The Act was an attempt to make it easier for authorities to prosecute organisations where a corporate management failing caused a fatality. The Act did not change the position of individuals (who continue to be prosecuted under the existing law of gross negligence manslaughter). Neither did it create a bar to parallel proceedings by the Health and Safety Executive (“HSE”), who continue with their work under the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974 (“HSWA”).

There can be little doubt that prosecutions under the Act have not been as widespread as might originally have been anticipated. Even when an organisation is put on trial, a conviction is far from guaranteed. Data published by the Crown Prosecution Service (“CPS”) shows that, by the end of 2023, there had been 40 corporate manslaughter prosecutions resulting in 29 convictions. More recent Parliamentary figures show that, during the three years from 2022/23 to 2024/25, a further 13 prosecutions were brought, resulting in 10 convictions. Notwithstanding those additional cases, prosecutions under the Act remain relatively infrequent, averaging only a handful each year since 2008.

There is an argument that the profile of the legislation and the emphasis placed on the penalties have contributed to long-term improvements in workplace safety. HSE’s latest figures show that 126 workers were killed in work-related accidents in Great Britain in 2025/26, compared with 247 in 2006/07, shortly before the Act came into force. While annual figures inevitably fluctuate from year to year, the longer-term trend suggests a substantial reduction in workplace fatalities over the period since the Act was introduced.

One factor which might influence the route a prosecution takes is the availability of time and resources. In the case of Lion Steel Equipment Limited (“Lion Steel”), where a worker fell to his death through a fragile roof panel, the prosecution was estimated to have cost around £140,000. An interesting component of that case was the willingness of the CPS to simultaneously prosecute individual directors, which in turn may have put pressure on the corporate entity to plead guilty, highlighting a potential conundrum for directors. Gross negligence manslaughter carries a maximum sentence of life imprisonment, and that could make a director feel vulnerable enough to prioritise their personal position over that of the organisation.

There is certainly a balance to be struck between the economic consequences of prosecution and the greater likelihood of conviction under health and safety legislation. Given the stringent duties imposed by the HSWA, many offences are evidentially easier to prove, which may continue to encourage regulators and prosecutors to pursue cases under that regime rather than under the Act. A recent prosecution provides an interesting example. In February 2026, corporate manslaughter charges against a very large organisation were ultimately not pursued after guilty pleas were accepted under the HSWA. The company was subsequently fined £2.475 million [Double fatality corporate manslaughter trial of a VLO ends up with a HSWA 1974 sentence – Crown Office Chambers].

Two of the larger organisations convicted under the Act (Geotechnical Holdings Ltd and Lion Steel) were still relatively small businesses, and it was because management had failed to take appropriate steps to protect employees that convictions were secured. More recent convictions demonstrate that the Act continues to be used across a broader range of organisations. Fairytales Day Nursery Limited pleaded guilty to corporate manslaughter and was fined £240,000 in April 2026, while UK Athletics was fined £350,000 in June 2026 after admitting corporate manslaughter following the death of Paralympian Abdullah Hayayei. Nevertheless, many convictions under the Act have involved small and medium-sized organisations, with no major listed company yet having been convicted of corporate manslaughter. This raises questions as to whether the practical difficulties of identifying senior management failings within larger and more complex organisations are limiting the Act’s application. Had convicted organisations possessed more sophisticated management structures, they may have escaped due to the difficulty of identifying management failings, and this clearly cannot have been the intention.

As is common in many scenarios, contracts of insurance can overlap, and this is the case with General Liability (“GL”) covers (Public Liability and Employers’ Liability) and Management Liability (“ML”). Many GL insurers will provide legal protection under a ‘Defence of Legal Rights’ provision or similar. This will typically include cover for ‘Insured Persons’ facing criminal prosecution, or a formal investigation or disciplinary hearing brought by a regulatory body. The view from D&O lawyers is often more straightforward, namely that GL will cover the organisation, whilst D&O is fundamentally designed to cover the management team for their breaches of duty and actual or alleged wrongful acts.

Whilst this works in theory, it rarely seems to be that clear cut. To complicate matters further, the emergence of Corporate Legal Liability (“CLL”) as an extension to ML policies has further blurred these lines. It is therefore no surprise to sometimes see a tug of war taking place between insurers, particularly whilst a decision is made on whether, and whom, to prosecute. One of the stronger arguments is that GL represents the more specific cover, a position supported by the standard approach on ML contracts of excluding claims ‘for’ bodily injury. Nonetheless, there is no neat and convenient dovetail and much will depend on both the factual matrix and the respective quality of the GL and ML contracts.

From an ML perspective, the position has not fundamentally changed. The statistical risk to managers remains relatively low, but a serious accident can expose directors to a lengthy period of anxiety, reputational damage and substantial fines (which insurance is generally prohibited from funding). Affirmative cover may provide up to £500,000 of defence costs cover for claims against the organisation for corporate manslaughter. This is in addition to defence costs cover for claims against individuals arising from criminal proceedings for manslaughter. Policies may also provide cover for costs associated with Health and Safety investigations against the organisation and insured persons (as defined).

Ultimately, however, there remains no clearly marked roadmap as to how a claim will develop. Whilst the Act has undeniably changed the legal landscape, the relatively small number of prosecutions and convictions, coupled with the continuing preference for prosecution under health and safety legislation, means that it remains practically impossible to identify a defined or standardised claims pathway. The uncertainty that existed when the Act was introduced continues, to a large extent, to exist today.

Corporate Manslaughter and Management Liability

Corporate Manslaughter and Management Liability

PDF, 206 KB

Neil McCarthy

Neil McCarthy

Before founding MPR, Neil spent over twenty years underwriting and managing financial lines insurance with Chubb, developing, launching and managing products across all financial lines classes of insurance.

Based in Manchester, and having run Chubb’s UK & Ireland Management Liability business, Neil is a strong advocate of regional broking. He has been a Fellow of the Chartered Insurance Institute since 1999.

Direct line:
0161 241 3551
Mobile:
07801 241844
Email:
nmccarthy@mprunderwriting.com

Subscribe for regular Broker Updates

Get regular insurance insights, news and updates direct to your mailbox.

* indicates required

Share Insight

Related Insights

View all Insights

Crime – Ten Private Company Claim Examples
Insight Crime

Crime – Ten Private Company Claim Examples

BDO's FraudTrack 2026 reported that the value of UK fraud and economic crime reached £5.5 billion during 2025, highlighting the significant and evolving threat that fraud continues to pose to businesses and individuals across the UK.
Anthony Wright Anthony Wright
• 5 min read
Cyber Insurance – Once More Unto the Breach
Factsheet Cyber

Cyber Insurance – Once More Unto the Breach

The cyber market has seen some recent instability. A wave of cyber events (particularly Ransomware) drove harder market conditions and the raising of the bar on cyber security requirements. This has attracted new insurers and competition is intensifying again.
Tim Jones Tim Jones
• 3 min read
The Significance of Extended Reporting Periods
Language Matters D&O/Management Risks

The Significance of Extended Reporting Periods

It is abundantly clear that not all Management Liability (“ML”) policy wordings are of the same quality. The difference is perhaps more acutely observed when comparing off line language with e-traded/statement of fact based policies.
Neil McCarthy Neil McCarthy
• 3 min read
We are Chartered Insurance Underwriting Agents