Whatever Happened to
the Major Shareholder Exclusion?
Written by
Neil McCarthy
At the Championship play-off final in 2010, Blackpool Football Club sold 37,000 tickets for their match against Cardiff City. Seven years later, when they returned to Wembley for the League Two play-off final against Exeter City, fewer than 5,000 supporters made the trip.
Whilst the prize on offer may have been less glamorous, the dramatic difference in attendance was driven largely by opposition to the club’s ownership and management. Away from the pitch, an arguably more significant contest was taking place in the courts. A minority shareholder, Valeri Belokon, had filed an unfair prejudice petition under section 994 of the Companies Act 2006, ultimately securing a £31.27 million award against the Oyston family in 2017.
The case highlighted an underwriting inconsistency that had existed for many years. The Major Shareholder Exclusion (“MSE”) was a long-standing comfort blanket for underwriters, either built into the fabric of a policy or included as an almost ever-present endorsement. And yet whilst minority shareholder claims have long represented a genuine exposure, as in the case of Blackpool FC, remedies available to major shareholders have historically been far more constrained.
The logic for the MSE was sensible enough. In organisations where a controlling interest was held by a family, founder, trust or other dominant shareholder, underwriters were reluctant to become embroiled in what they saw as internal disputes. The reality, however, was that the prevailing legal framework never really supported this position. Under English law, shareholders are generally unable to recover losses that merely reflect those suffered by the company itself, a principle known as “reflective loss”. This prevents shareholders from claiming for a fall in the value of their shares or a reduction in dividends where it is the company that has suffered the underlying loss. Claims by a major shareholder alleging negligence, breach of duty or mismanagement by directors faced a fundamental obstacle in that the rightful claimant was the company, not the shareholder.
In limited circumstances shareholders may seek permission to pursue a derivative claim on behalf of the company. However, such actions remain uncommon, require court approval and can only proceed where the statutory requirements are satisfied. Even where successful, any recovery belongs to the company rather than the shareholder personally. The MSE was therefore excluding claims that, in most circumstances, could not be brought by shareholders in their own right under English law. Where a claim did exist, it belonged to the company and fell outside the scope of the exclusion altogether.
Actions by minority shareholders under unfair prejudice petitions are common and often based on (ironically) conduct by major shareholders, where it is alleged that the company’s affairs have been conducted in a manner unfairly prejudicial to the minority’s interests. Such actions can be highly effective and, as they are typically brought by minority shareholders, the MSE offers little or no protection against them. That is not to say that disputes involving major shareholders do not arise. Fraud, misrepresentation or other personal causes of action may still be possible, whilst disputes between companies and their own directors remain a source of D&O exposure. Underwriters are now more likely to address those specific concerns through bespoke endorsements directed at particular individuals, organisations or known disputes rather than through the redundant MSE. And whilst it may still be found, what was once a trusty companion of D&O underwriters is now largely a relic of a bygone era.
Neil McCarthy
Before founding MPR, Neil spent over twenty years underwriting and managing financial lines insurance with Chubb, developing, launching and managing products across all financial lines classes of insurance.
Based in Manchester, and having run Chubb’s UK & Ireland Management Liability business, Neil is a strong advocate of regional broking. He has been a Fellow of the Chartered Insurance Institute since 1999.
- Direct line:
- 0161 241 3551
- Mobile:
- 07801 241844
- Email:
- nmccarthy@mprunderwriting.com
Subscribe for regular Broker Updates
Get regular insurance insights, news and updates direct to your mailbox.

