MPR Underwriting
MPR Underwriting
  • About
  • Team
  • Products
  • Insights
  • Resources
  • Contact
  • About
  • Team
  • Products
  • Insights
  • Resources
  • Contact
  • Linked in
  • Twitter
  • Data protection and privacy notice
  • Cookie Policy

‘Verbal’ – one word,
all the difference

  • Home
  • Insights
  • ‘Verbal’ – one word, all the difference

Insight

Professional Indemnity

    Any parent will tell you that you should only say something that you can follow up on. So, “Turn off that iPad or you’ll never see another screen for the rest of your life” really doesn’t work. It’s a threat, fuelled by frustration, that won’t be followed through. Parents know this and children work it out quickly too.

    The same pattern sometimes appears in business. When things go wrong, frustrated parties can act irrationally and may say things that won’t necessarily be followed up on. Imagine this phone call (between ‘Firm A’ and ‘Client B’) after something on a project has gone slightly wrong:

    Firm A – “yes, I agree that there seems to have been a bit of a mix up here, but give us a few hours and we’ll get it sorted for you”

    Client B – “This is unacceptable, and come to think of it, the work you’ve done for us has been poor all the way through and I’m going to be making a claim for your professional negligence for my financial loss of £150,000… click… dial tone…”

    It’s not difficult to imagine how common this scenario might be – we all have customers with different communication styles. In this example, Firm A recognises there may have been a misunderstanding, but feels confident knowing they can remedy any issues and fulfil their professional duties by delivering a good service to Client B. They’re also confident that Client B was just blowing off some steam as they’d been under pressure so they decide to give them a few days to cool down and then follow up. They look at their PI policy to make sure they don’t have to notify insurers and check the definition of ‘Claim’:

    Claim means a written, or verbal, demand for compensation or damages due to a wrongful act.

    The word ‘verbal’ is key here – Client B has made a verbal demand for compensation. So, now Firm A is in a potentially tricky situation. Under the terms of the policy, they must notify the insurers (the notification language states ‘as soon as practicable’) but they’re sure it was a heat of the moment threat that wouldn’t be followed up. Over the next couple of days, Firm A tried to get back in touch with Client B, but with no luck. Rather than run the risk of late notification (and having any potential claim declined), they decided to notify the insurer of the situation. The insurer marks up a claims file and advises Firm A to keep them informed.

    A week later, having implemented the process to solve the mix-up, they finally got in touch with Client B.

    Firm A – “Hi, we’ve been trying to get in touch – we fixed that issue for you so hope things have been resolved at your end?”

    Client B – “Yes, thanks – that did the trick actually. Sorry about the outburst the other day, we’ve been under a lot of pressure on this job and I let my frustrations get the better of me. You’ve done a good job and we won’t actually be making a claim” …

    Firm A is relieved and updates the insurer. The insurer notes the file and diaries it to close in 3 months if nothing more is heard. However, this potentially leaves a blemish on the claims record and could be something that Firm A would have to declare on future PI applications.

    So, it’s worth checking what the policy states in relation to the claims definitions. One word, whilst seemingly insignificant, can make a big difference. Without it, Firm A would be safe in the knowledge that, until Client B made a written demand, they would not have to notify the insurer and it would not constitute a claim under their PI policy. They would resolve the issue in the usual way without the involvement of insurers and the potential blotting of their copybook.

    Tim Jones

    Written by

    Tim Jones

    Insight

    Any One Claim & D&O:
    Much Ado About Nothing?

    As Shakespeare conveyed in Hamlet, “There is nothing good or bad, only thinking makes it so.” No event or occurrence is truly good or bad, they are based on our cognitive processing and pre-suppositions.

    News

    MPR Update – February 2020

    Latest news, market updates and product information from MPR.

    Insight

    Recovery of assets following
    an employee fraud

    The Association of Certified Fraud Examiners estimates that, on average, 6% of the turnover of an organisation is lost to employee fraud.

    10th Floor
    Chancery Place
    50 Brown Street
    Manchester
    M2 2JG

    0161 241 3550
    enquiries@mprunderwriting.com

    • About
    • Team
    • Our Products
    • Insights
    • Resources
    • Contact
    • Data protection and privacy notice
    • Cookie Policy
    • Linked in
    • Twitter
    MPR are Chartered Insurance Underwriting Agents

    MPR Underwriting Limited is a company incorporated in England and Wales. Registered Address: 10th Floor, Chancery Place, 50 Brown Street, Manchester, M2 2JG. Company Number: 10529758. Authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.

    Privacy Policy and Cookie Information

    We use a small number of cookies on this website to make the website as useful as possible. None of these cookies collect any personal information. To find out more about these cookies and how to control their use, see our Read More.

    Close