MPR Underwriting
MPR Underwriting
  • About
  • Team
  • Products
  • Insights
  • Resources
  • Contact
  • About
  • Team
  • Products
  • Insights
  • Resources
  • Contact
  • Linked in
  • Twitter
  • Data protection and privacy notice
  • Cookie Policy

D&O and the
Duty to Defend

  • Home
  • Insights
  • D&O and the Duty to Defend

Language Matters

D&O/Management Risks

    The ‘duty to defend’ is a long-standing provision in D&O policies and, in broad terms, allows the appointment of a lawyer to be the choice of the insured person(s). Due to the range and potential complexity of claims within the D&O environment, having the relevant competence and experience is important. Expertise can vary dramatically and having more choice to enable the appointment of someone with the appropriate background is unquestionably preferable.

    Notwithstanding this, because the insurer is potentially paying, they do need to know what is happening, so they will always seek to reserve the right to associate on any investigation, defence, negotiation and settlement, and would need to be consulted prior to any spend against the policy (this essentially allows the validation of lawyer choice together with the rates and, ultimately, litigation strategy). Duty to defend language would typically read:

    “It shall be the duty of each Insured and not the duty of the Insurer to defend Claims.” 

    Some policy wordings prescribe who an insured person(s) has to use, or may impose limited caps on hourly rates, and this needs to be considered for potential disadvantages, but the duty to defend position is taken for a number of good reasons, some of which include:

    1) in criminal matters, where a director may be facing potential imprisonment, it might be considered inappropriate to compel an insured to use an insurers choice of lawyer, if they were not comfortable in doing so;

    2) elements of claims may not fall for cover (see Allocation in D&O Policies – MPR Underwriting) and, again, insurers ought not to be able to compel the use of certain lawyers where the policy may not respond to some of the defence costs or loss that might be incurred;

    3) often, D&O insurers are not in a position to confirm cover at the time of instruction, so they cannot reasonably insist on compelling the use of a lawyer the insured person(s) might not otherwise choose; and

    4) panel lawyers may be unsuited for claims in certain territories, typically overseas.

    This contrasts with the Employment Practices Liability environment, where the respondent to the claim is almost always the organisation itself and a more prescriptive approach is possible and, arguably, more appropriate. In the D&O environment, however, direction to a sole solution or a more limited panel can fail to provide sufficient depth in quality and breadth of choice and is a move away from a more traditional D&O language approach.

    In the D&O environment, however, direction to a sole solution or a more limited panel can fail to provide sufficient depth in quality and breadth of choice and is a move away from a more traditional D&O language approach.

    Download PDF

    Neil McCarthy

    Written by

    Neil McCarthy

    Language Matters

    Allocation in D&O
    Policies

    There is little doubt that Directors & Officers (‘D&O’) Liability is a sophisticated product which contains potentially complex concepts and processes. Despite the low profile in a D&O policy features showreel, ‘allocation’ is nonetheless a key component of any contract and plays a role in all claims.

    Insight

    Any One Claim & D&O:
    Much Ado About Nothing?

    As Shakespeare conveyed in Hamlet, "There is nothing good or bad, only thinking makes it so." No event or occurrence is truly good or bad, they are based on our cognitive processing and pre-suppositions.

    Insight

    D&O – do you need to run off?

    A ‘need’ is something that is necessary for an organism to live a healthy life, which, for as enthusiastic as we are about D&O insurance, is something of an ambitious claim.

    10th Floor
    Chancery Place
    50 Brown Street
    Manchester
    M2 2JG

    0161 241 3550
    enquiries@mprunderwriting.com

    • About
    • Team
    • Our Products
    • Insights
    • Resources
    • Contact
    • Data protection and privacy notice
    • Cookie Policy
    • Linked in
    • Twitter
    MPR are Chartered Insurance Underwriting Agents

    MPR Underwriting Limited is a company incorporated in England and Wales. Registered Address: 10th Floor, Chancery Place, 50 Brown Street, Manchester, M2 2JG. Company Number: 10529758. Authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.

    Privacy Policy and Cookie Information

    We use a small number of cookies on this website to make the website as useful as possible. None of these cookies collect any personal information. To find out more about these cookies and how to control their use, see our Read More.

    Close